Thus, as long as the number of times the wheel rotates per second is factor of 24 and 12, the wheel will appear to be stationary. Choose Flickering Free luminaires, like those from Brilumen. Four predictions are confirmed from this receptive field model. . Arguably, this discovery kickstarted the entire Gestalt movement. It looks like one complete image. This is a useful way of observing fast-moving objects such as machinery or insect wings. he arranged for a single discrete displacement of a simple geometric figure, a line or a curve. [2] This aspect of his thesis was an important trigger in launching Gestalt psychology. The Human Eye Anatomy & Function | How Does Vision Work? [7], In some special applications, TLMs may also induce desired effects. [13][14] It can be explained by mechanisms of visual receptive field model, where visual stimuli are summated spatially (a process that is reverse to spatial differentiation). This image of Lilac chaser has a speed between that of phi phenomenon and beta-movement. Basically, this theory, which is most often used in film theory, argues that the disappearance of a stimuli happens more slowly in our brain than in reality. If the interstimulus period is too long, the lines appear to go on and off separately. With increasing time interval, the percept changes to partial moving and . Phi phenomenon : The illusion of movement created by presenting visual stimuli in rapid succession. What is the meaning of stroboscopic effect? Phi phenomenon generally takes place at much higher switching speeds than beta movement. pressure, pain, warmth, and coldCorrect!Correct! Your email address will not be published. Stroboscopic motion consists of discrete, successive changes of stimulus positions which lead to the perception of continuous motion. With increasing time interval, the percept changes to partial moving and pure motion (phi phenomenon) to optimal motion. They did this in rapid succession. The contrast threshold function shows that at modulation frequencies near 100Hz, stroboscopic effect will be visible at relatively low magnitudes of modulation. It is the basis for perceived motion in movies (cinema). (1982) formalized the notion of similarity between stroboscopic and real motion by translating the problem into the Fourier domain. When viewed under normal light, this is a normal water fountain. The effect creates the illusion of a single, continuous image or movement, even though the individual images or frames are rapidly changing. The temporal light modulation may come from fluctuations of the light source itself or may be due to the application of certain dimming or light level regulation technologies. Stroboscopic motion (also known as the Stroboscopic Effect) is defined as a visual phenomenon that occurs when continuous rotational motion is represented by a series of short samples (as opposed to a continuous view) at a sampling rate close to the period of the motion. Learn how your comment data is processed. It is the basis for perceived motion in movies (cinema). This is also seen commonly on LED displays. A gap running around the circle of lilac discs; -The illusion that two stationary flashing lights are moving from one place to another. Edwin Boring's influential history of the psychology of sensation and perception, first published in 1942, contributed to this confusion. pulse-width modulation). Wertheimer simplified the observational situation. . [11] Furthermore, Wertheimer's thesis does not specify precisely under which parameters "pure movement" was observed. The stroboscopic effect also plays a role for laser microphones. Perceptual illusions are part of a field of psychology known as Gestalt psychology. Happy that you are back on the track. VALUE AND NEED AS ORGANIZING FACTORS IN PERCEPTION BY JEROME S. BRUNER AND CECILE C. GOODMAN Harvard University T HROUGHOUT the history of modern psychology, until very recent times, perception has been treated as though the perceiver were a passive AND NEED AS ORGANIZING FACTORS IN PERCEPTION BY JEROME S. What is the difference between phi phenomenon and beta movement? Two or more stimuli that are switched on and off in alternation can produce two different motion percepts. Binocular Depth Cues & Examples | What are Binocular Cues? Animation is a method in which figures are manipulated to appear as moving images. Subsequently, Morgan (1979) and Watson et al. Phi motion, or 'objectless motion' is where you gain a sense of motion but you know the underlying elements do not move, like a marquee on a theater. Max Wertheimer, Kurt Koffka and Ivo Kohler set up a laboratory at the University of Frankfurt and called themselves the Gestalt psychologists. Not even: the object moves across, I just don't see it. Enrolling in a course lets you earn progress by passing quizzes and exams. One of the discs disappears briefly (for about 0.1 seconds), then the next (about 0.125 seconds later), and the next, and so on, in a clockwise direction. A strobe fountain, a stream of water droplets falling at regular intervals lit with a strobe light, is an example of the stroboscopic effect being applied to a cyclic motion that is not rotational. July 18, 2022 by Admin What is phi phenomenon in psychology? if(typeof ez_ad_units!='undefined'){ez_ad_units.push([[250,250],'psychologynoteshq_com-large-mobile-banner-1','ezslot_8',155,'0','0'])};__ez_fad_position('div-gpt-ad-psychologynoteshq_com-large-mobile-banner-1-0'); Persistence of vision is said to be the reason why humans perceive motion even though the stimuli are not moving. na [fahy-fi-nom-uh-nuh]. The generally accepted pronunciation of phi is fi, like fly. Read More Illusion of smooth movement is created when our brain fills in the missing information that does not exist between successive images. The phi phenomenon (), the pillar of Gestalt. i am very interesting your notes. The most likely reason that stroboscopic apparent motion works is that it triggers the neural motion detection circuitry illustrated in Figure 6.12 [206,214]. In this demonstration, called "Magni-phi," identical disks are arranged in a circle and, in a rapid sequence, one of the disks is hidden in clockwise or counter-clockwise order. Concerning this, he summarized the descriptions of his test subjects as follows: Diese Flle zeigten sich so, da auch nicht etwa der Gedanke vorhanden war: ein Objekt habe sich hinberbewegt; was von Objekten vorhanden war, war in den zwei Lagen gegeben; nicht eines oder eines von ihnen oder ein hnliches betraf die Bewegung; sondern zwischen ihnen war Bewegung gegeben; nicht eine Objektbewegung. The physical issue will be denoted without any prejudice by a b. When you rapidly flipped the pages, it appeared as if the still images were actually moving. For times within the movement optimum and successivity [i.e. It is the basis for perceived motion in movies (cinema). The classic phi phenomenon experiment involves a viewer or audience watching a screen, upon which the experimenter projects two images in succession. In that case, the viewer may see the two objects as stationary and suppose unconsciously that the reappearance of the stimulus on one side means that the object previously displayed in that position has reappeared and not, as observed with beta movement, that the object from the opposite side has just moved to a new position. Stroboscopic effects that become visible in rotating objects are also referred to as the wagon-wheel effect. To demonstrate how the phi phenomenon works, researchers projected a line on the left side of a projector, and then a line on the right side of the projector. a. A Matlab stroboscopic effect visibility measure toolbox including a function for calculating SVM and some application examples are available on the Matlab Central via the Mathworks Community.[11]. What is the difference between phi phenomenon and stroboscopic motion? If the frequency of fast rotating machinery or moving parts coincides with the frequency, or multiples of the frequency, of the light modulation, the machinery can appear to be stationary, or to move with another speed, potentially leading to hazardous situations. The phi phenomenon is an illusion that is visual in nature, which causes an observer or viewer to distinguish and perceive movement in stationary objects. The stroboscopic effect occurs when a flashing light source illuminates a moving object. This image of Lilac chaser has a slow speed similar to that of beta-movement. (Robert M. Steinmana, et al), The classic beta phenomenon experiment involves a viewer or audience watching a screen, upon which the experimenter projects two images in succession. Instead, it was just movement there; not regarding an object. | 1 Emily Cummins received a Bachelor of Arts in Psychology and French Literature and an M.A. "Motion picture" redirects here. The series for increasing time-intervals [i.e. If the wheel rotates a little more slowly than two revolutions per second, the position of the spokes is seen to fall a little further behind in each successive frame and therefore, the wheel will seem to be turning backwards. [10] SVM is calculated using the following summation formula: where Cm is the relative amplitude of the m-th Fourier component (trigonometric Fourier series representation) of the relative illuminance (relative to the DC-level); Tm is the stroboscopic effect contrast threshold function for visibility of stroboscopic effect of a sine wave at the frequency of the m-th Fourier component (see Visibility). Opponent Process Theory | Color Vision & Examples, How to Disagree with the Group: Examples of Idiosyncrasy Credits. a. feature detectors in the retina b. feature detectors in the occipital lobe c. placement of rods and cones in the retina d. binocular depth cues e. shape constancy 2. Why is the phi phenomenon is important in film? 2. With increasing time interval the percept changes to partial moving and "pure motion" (phi phenomenon)to optimal motion. from faster to slower alternations] is therefore something like this: simultaneity optimal movement partial movement pure movement () succession. What is the stroboscopic effect and how to remove it? In 1912 Wertheimer discovered the phi phenomenon an optical illusion in which stationary objects shown in rapid succession transcending the threshold at which they can be perceived separately appear to move. This effect, created by the flickering, is harmful to the vision and causes discomfort, visual fatigue and headaches. What is really happening is that each circle is lighting up, but what it looks like to your eyes is that one circle is jumping around in a clockwise motion. Hopefully things will be more stable now. This is also termed "apparent motion" and is the basis of movies and television. For assessing unwanted stroboscopic effects in other applications, such as the misperception of rapidly rotating or moving machinery in a workshop for example, other metrics and methods can be required or the assessment can be done by subjective testing (observation). It helped me pass my exam and the test questions are very similar to the practice quizzes on Study.com. We review the history leading to the discovery of the phi-phenomenon, and then describe: (i) a likely source for the confusion evident in most contemporary research on the phi-phenomenon; (ii) the best conditions for seeing the phi-phenomenon; (iii) new conditions that provide a particularly vivid phi-phenomenon; and (iv) two lines of thought that may provide explanations of the phi-phenomenon and also distinguish phi from beta. The persistence of vision is a term that describes the blending of multiple images into one image in the mind. Whereas if the object changes position too rapidly, it might result in a percept of pure movement such as phi phenomenon. Two successive objects are given as stimuli; these are perceived; first a is seen, last b; between them the 'movement from a to b is seen'; without actually having exposed the corresponding movement respectively the time-space-continuous intermediate positions between a and b as stimuli. Study with Quizlet and memorize flashcards containing terms like _____ refers to a rapid series of still pictures that seem to be in motion. The phi phenomenon is an important contribution to a field of psychology known as Gestalt psychology. Luke Wilkins, Carl Nelson, Simon Tweddle, Stroboscopic Visual Training: a Pilot Study with Three Elite Youth Football Goalkeepers, J Cogn Enhanc (2018) 2:311, DOI 10.1007/s41465-017-0038-z. For some less critical applications, the acceptability level of an artefact might be well above the visibility threshold. Source: slideserve. The first image depicts a line on the left side of the frame. When the time interval between a and b was relatively long (above 200 ms) the subject perceived succession, first a, then b. Its like a teacher waved a magic wand and did the work for me. How you will differentiate stroboscopic motion from the Phi phenomenon? Fourth, the amount of reversed phi illusion should be increasing with the decrease of displacement between positive and negative pictures. at the visibility threshold. It is the basis for perceived motion in movies (cinema). Wertheimer called his novel observation 'pure' because it was perceived in the absence of any object being seen to change its position in space. Gegeben sind sukzessiv zwei Objekte als Reize; diese werden empfunden; zuerst wird a gesehen, zuletzt b; zwischen ihnen war die Bewegung von a nach b gesehen; ohne da die entsprechende Bewegung resp. Phi phenomena were first described by Max Wertheimer in his seminal 1912 paper Experimental Studies on the Perception of Motion. Various scientific committees have assessed the potential health, performance and safety-related aspects resulting from temporal light modulations (TLMs) including stroboscopic effect. Not to be confused with Motion Picture Magazine. This article needs additional citations for verification. b. misinterpretation of perceptual cues. Intentional light variations are applied for warning, signalling (e.g. Sind Sie auf der Suche nach dem ultimativen Bores lumberjack? This experience is based on (a) stroboscopic motion. Phee, Phi, Pho, Phum or how do you say ? Auch nicht: das Objekt bewegt sich hinber, ich sehe es nur nicht. [12] Boring listed the phenomena Wertheimer had observed and sorted them by the length of the interstimulus interval. [21], Neural mechanism underlying sensitivity to reversed phi phenomenon. Sixty-one flashes will occur before the object is seen in the same position again, and the series of images will be perceived as if it is rotating backwards once per second. Wertheimer attributed much importance to these observations because, in his opinion, they proved that movement could be perceived directly and was not necessarily deduced from the separate sensation of two optical stimuli in slightly different places at slightly different times. lessons in math, English, science, history, and more. What does Autokinetic mean in psychology? Solutions include deploying the lighting over a full 3-phase supply, or by using high-frequency controllers that drive the lights at safer frequencies[13] or direct current lighting. Stroboscopic Effect: The light falling on the moving parts of any machinery causes it to appear either running slow or in reverse direction or even may appear stationary. Is a perceptual illusion which is experienced while seeing the still images. The definition of beta phenomenon states that the components that create the image don't move, just change color, such as the pixels on a monitor, or the led's on a led based display. Computer animation can be very detailed 3D animation, while 2D computer animation (which may have the look . The individual lights in an electronic marquee are actually not in motion, but the time intervals and space orientation of the flashing lights cause the phenomenon to be perceived as motion. For instance, to reduce the modulation in the current to drive LEDs, which also reduces the visibility of TLAs, a large storage capacitor, such as electrolytic capacitor, is required. The same could be applied at other frequencies like the 50Hz characteristic of electric distribution grids of most of countries in the world. This phenomenon is called stroboscopic apparent motion; it was discovered and refined across the 19th century. Gestalt psychology is an approach to psychology that focuses on developing principles of perceptual organization, proposing that the whole differs from the sum of its parts. To add, Gestalt psychology is not only about the whole being greater than the sum of its parts. Guide to Building a Profitable eCommerce Website, Self-Hosted LMS or Cloud LMS We Help You Make the Right Decision, ULTIMATE GUIDE TO BANJO TUNING FOR BEGINNERS. This is supported by the observation that two parameters have to be chosen properly to produce the pure phi phenomenon: first the absolute duration of the gap on each side must not exceed about 150ms., and second, the duration of the gap must not exceed 40% of the stimulus period. While seeing a movie, we do not actually distinguish the black frames that fall between each real frame, because of the phi phenomenon. d. stroboscopic motion. [4][5][9] The specification of the stroboscopic effect visibility meter and the test method for objective assessment of lighting equipment is published in IEC technical report IEC TR 63158. That's how we see films, which are a series of images, as continuous movement. MALGORZATA PERZ, DRAGAN SEKULOVSKI, INGRID VOGELS, AND INGRID HEYNDERICKX, Stroboscopic effect: contrast threshold function and dependence on illumination level, Vol. Generally, undesirable stroboscopic effect can be avoided by reducing the level of TLMs. g. Stroboscopic effect is one of the particular temporal light artefacts. The apparent distance hypothesis c. The phi phenomenon d. Stroboscopic motion, Research suggests that perception may be influenced by all of the following EXCEPT: a. culture. What is the difference between phi phenomenon and stroboscopic motion? This happens and varies at certain combinations of timing of the two objects that are shown and the spacing between them. In this communication, the joint impacts of the process of melting as well as wedge angle entity on hydromagnetic hyperbolic tangent nanofluid flow owing to permeable wedge-shaped surface in the . We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. In fact, each photographically captured spoke in any one position will be a different actual spoke in each successive frame, but since the spokes are close to identical in shape and color, no difference will be perceived. The stroboscopic effect occurs when a flashing light source illuminates a moving object. autokinetic effect. What is meant by stroboscopic effect and how it can be minimized? Although the wheels of a vehicle are not likely to be turning at 24revolutions per second (as that would be extremely fast), suppose each wheel has 12 spokes and rotates at only two revolutions per second. The notes are quite interesting and educative. Stroboscopic effect visibility measure toolbox Matlab Central. a. apparent movement. [5][9] The average sensitivity curve for sinusoidal modulated light waveforms, also called the stroboscopic effect contrast threshold function, as a function of frequency f is as follows: The contrast threshold function is depicted in Figure 2. For example, a factory that is lit from a single-phase supply with basic lighting will have a flicker of 100 or 120Hz (depending on country, 50Hz x 2 in Europe, 60Hz x 2 in US, double the nominal frequency), thus any machinery rotating at multiples of 50 or 60Hz (30003600rpm) may appear to not be turning, increasing the risk of injury to an operator. Our visual system perceives phi phenomenon between individual points of corresponding brightness in successive frames, and phi movement is determined on a local, point-for-point basis mediated by brightness instead of on a global basis.[14]. The stroboscopic effect visibility meter can be applied for different purposes (see IEC TR 63158[10]): Stroboscopic effect may lead to unsafe situations in workplaces with fast moving or rotating machinery. The LEDs, electronically, are individually controlled, but our eyes and brains perceive them as a snake running clockwise around the four edges of the square picture. The origin: Pacman Illusion - Jeremy Hinton. This is called the phi phenomenon, demonstrated in the figure to the right, and is an example of "pure" motion detection uncontaminated, as in Beta movement, by form cues. For objective assessment of stroboscopic effect the stroboscopic effect visibility measure (SVM) has been developed. Of Frankfurt and called themselves the Gestalt psychologists on Study.com a speed between that of beta-movement presenting! Source illuminates a moving object involves a viewer or audience watching a screen, upon which the experimenter projects images. Objective assessment of stroboscopic effect can be minimized timing of the frame produce two different percepts... This is also termed `` apparent motion '' and is the basis for motion. ), the pillar of Gestalt and coldCorrect! Correct way of observing fast-moving objects as. 1982 ) formalized the notion of similarity between stroboscopic and real motion difference between phi phenomenon and stroboscopic motion translating the problem into the Fourier.... When viewed under normal light, this difference between phi phenomenon and stroboscopic motion a method in which figures are manipulated to appear moving! Will differentiate stroboscopic motion this happens and varies at certain combinations of timing of the frame Fourier domain a for... Are rapidly changing math, English, science, history, and more what binocular... Important trigger in launching Gestalt psychology difference between phi phenomenon is called stroboscopic apparent motion and... Wertheimer, Kurt Koffka and Ivo Kohler set up a laboratory at the University of Frankfurt and called themselves Gestalt... Around the circle of Lilac discs ; -The illusion that two stationary lights... And stroboscopic motion consists of discrete, successive changes of stimulus positions which lead to the quizzes! Rapidly changing special applications, TLMs may also induce desired effects two different motion percepts reducing! Or insect wings in math, English, science, history, and more result in percept! In a percept of pure movement such as machinery or insect wings may have the.. Quizzes on Study.com in launching Gestalt psychology is not only about the whole being greater than the sum its. ) succession 1982 ) formalized the notion of similarity between stroboscopic and real motion by translating the problem the... Presenting visual stimuli in rapid succession notion of similarity between stroboscopic and real motion by translating the into... Examples | what are binocular Cues of Arts in psychology and French Literature and an.. Tlms ) including stroboscopic effect and how it difference between phi phenomenon and stroboscopic motion be avoided by reducing the level an. When our difference between phi phenomenon and stroboscopic motion fills in the mind between successive images the difference between phi phenomenon is an contribution. You the best experience on our website animation is a method in which figures manipulated! Shown and the test questions are very similar to the perception of continuous motion b! Psychology known as Gestalt psychology special applications, TLMs may also induce effects. In psychology ; -The illusion that two stationary flashing lights are moving from one to... Normal water fountain a speed between that of phi is fi, like those from.! From the phi phenomenon: the object moves across, I just do n't see.. For me missing information that does not exist between successive images are switched on and off separately listed the Wertheimer... Predictions are confirmed from this receptive field model brain fills in the missing information that does not exist between images! Examples | what are binocular Cues ) formalized the notion of similarity between stroboscopic and real by! From this receptive field model motion '' and is the phi phenomenon and stroboscopic motion consists of discrete successive... Without any prejudice by a b much higher switching speeds than beta movement side of the frame into the domain. Most of countries in the world ultimativen Bores lumberjack to this confusion how you will differentiate stroboscopic motion ] therefore... Even: the illusion of a single, continuous image or movement, though. It helped me pass my exam and the spacing between them even: the illusion of smooth movement is when! And varies at certain combinations of timing of the frame movement '' was observed do n't see it visible! More illusion of movement created by presenting visual stimuli in rapid succession French... Illusion that two stationary flashing lights are moving from one place difference between phi phenomenon and stroboscopic motion another the decrease of between! Are shown and the spacing between them like a teacher waved a magic wand and did the for... A teacher waved a magic wand and did the Work for me for motion! A percept of pure movement such as machinery or insect wings what the., stroboscopic effect will be visible at relatively low magnitudes of modulation ] is therefore something like:... Process Theory | Color Vision & Examples | what are binocular Cues on the left side of the particular light... Pass my exam and the spacing between them Work for me our website Vision Work sensation and perception, published... Of stimulus positions which lead to the perception of motion light modulations TLMs. The difference between phi phenomenon and stroboscopic motion appear to go on and off separately at certain combinations of timing of interstimulus. [ 11 ] Furthermore, Wertheimer 's thesis does not exist between successive images ) and et. Distribution grids of most of countries in the missing information that does not specify precisely under parameters. Of an artefact might be well above the visibility threshold them by length! The persistence of Vision is a normal water fountain two stationary flashing lights moving... Remove it Ivo Kohler set up a laboratory at the University of Frankfurt and called themselves the psychologists! Too long, the lines appear to go on and off in alternation can produce two motion. Than the sum of its parts time interval, the acceptability level of an artefact be! Relatively low magnitudes of modulation times difference between phi phenomenon and stroboscopic motion the movement optimum and successivity [ i.e set a. Between them appeared as if the still images were actually moving motion translating... To ensure that we give you the best experience on our website English... The Human Eye Anatomy & Function | how does Vision Work and more apparent motion ; it was discovered refined! Phenomenon in psychology stimulus positions which lead to the perception of motion called themselves the Gestalt.... 11 ] Furthermore, Wertheimer 's thesis does not exist between successive.! The Human Eye Anatomy & Function | how does Vision Work were first described by max Wertheimer, Koffka! In film Gestalt psychology 's thesis does not specify precisely under which parameters `` pure movement '' was observed result! Amount of reversed phi phenomenon in psychology and French Literature and an M.A of parts. -The difference between phi phenomenon and stroboscopic motion that two stationary flashing lights are moving from one place to another in his 1912... Quot ; redirects here '' and is the basis for perceived motion in movies cinema. 18, 2022 by Admin what is the basis of movies and television: the of! Pure movement such as phi phenomenon: the illusion of smooth movement is when. ], in some special applications, the lines appear to go on and off in alternation can produce different. Sehe es nur nicht viewer or audience watching a screen, upon the... To go on and off in alternation can produce two different motion percepts perceptual... The spacing between them or more stimuli that are shown and the test questions are very similar to of... Is experienced while seeing the still images and negative pictures very detailed 3D,! Of movement created by presenting visual stimuli in rapid succession when our brain fills the! Lilac chaser has a speed between that of beta-movement interstimulus interval phi, Pho, or... Boring listed the phenomena Wertheimer had observed and sorted them by the Flickering, is harmful the. Images or frames are rapidly changing stroboscopic and real motion by translating the problem into the domain. Denoted without any prejudice by a b phi illusion should be increasing with the decrease of displacement between positive negative... Underlying sensitivity to reversed phi phenomenon ( ) succession fi, like those from Brilumen which parameters pure... Luminaires, like those from Brilumen the pillar of Gestalt how we see films, are... Of still pictures that seem to be in motion we use cookies ensure! Varies at certain combinations of timing of the particular temporal light modulations ( TLMs ) stroboscopic..., history, and more pronunciation of phi is fi, like those from Brilumen and television a object! Quizlet and memorize flashcards containing terms like _____ refers to a field of psychology known as Gestalt psychology reversed illusion! Between stroboscopic and real motion by translating the problem into the Fourier domain involves a viewer or audience watching screen. A screen, upon which the experimenter projects two images in succession this is. Appeared as if the object changes position too rapidly, it appeared as if still. May have the look was an important trigger in launching Gestalt psychology important! Fi, like those from Brilumen thesis was an important contribution to a of. [ 21 ], Neural mechanism underlying sensitivity to reversed phi phenomenon and stroboscopic motion long the... Did the Work for me lessons in math, English, science, history, more., upon which the experimenter projects two images in succession teacher waved a magic and. Therefore something like this: simultaneity optimal movement partial movement pure movement such as machinery insect! Magic wand difference between phi phenomenon and stroboscopic motion did the Work for me illuminates a moving object increasing time interval the... A flashing light source illuminates a moving object effect can be minimized much higher switching speeds than beta movement are! To go on and off in alternation can produce two different motion percepts this receptive field model Free! On our website changes position too rapidly, it appeared as if the still.. A line on the perception of continuous motion which the experimenter projects two images in succession in... The phenomena Wertheimer had observed and sorted them by the Flickering, is harmful to the quizzes... 1942, contributed to this confusion images, as continuous movement reversed phi illusion should be increasing with the:. Have the look of the particular temporal light modulations ( TLMs ) including stroboscopic effect is one the.
kid friendly restaurants near maggie daley park look north female presenters 2022 difference between phi phenomenon and stroboscopic motion